After some consideration, I have decided that the petrol consumption experiment involves too many variables that cannot be controlled adequately. I had an idea for a new experiment investigating the durability of different types of glue (wood, paper, waterproof, glue stick) in bonding different types of surfaces (porous and non porous). I will have to write up a formal method for this experiment.
The basic plan is to bond two surfaces with glue, wait for the glue to dry, and then incrementally increase the weight on the bond until it breaks.
Dependent variable: type of surface (porous/non porous), type of glue
Independent variable: Amount of weight held before the bond breaks
Controlled variables:
-- Surface area of glue: 1cm2
-- Amount of glue: 0.5mL (Luckily I have loads of tiny measuring syringes from medicating sick guinea pigs)
-- Weight of container... probably some sort of plastic bag, maybe a Snap-Lock sandwich bag?
-- Weight placed into bag: Water in 5mL (5g) increments
-- Amount of time glue allowed to dry before being tested: Probably 24-48 hours; I'll check the "recommended drying" times on glues and use the longest one.
-- Weather conditions of testing: Humidity, temperature etc. This probably won't be a problem as they'll all be in the same area, on the same day. The experiment will also be repeated several times on different days.
I think this experiment will be possible to carry out and control.
Showing posts with label experiment ideas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label experiment ideas. Show all posts
Saturday, May 8, 2010
Sunday, May 2, 2010
Back from holidays and starting experiment
I've finally returned from holidays so I can start posting on my blog again and doing my experiment. Un(?)fortunately I haven't been on any long drives yet, but this should (un)fortunately change. Also, I found out that when I turn 16, I'll be able to start learning to drive, so if I wanted I could be extra hands on with this experiment! Maybe that would be a little too dangerous...
Thanks to Izzy for pointing out some more variables I need to control -- whether the car airconditioning and stereo are on or off, which could burn extra petrol. Since it's winter, I'll get us to turn them off all the time that's being recorded, just to make it simpler.
Thanks to Izzy for pointing out some more variables I need to control -- whether the car airconditioning and stereo are on or off, which could burn extra petrol. Since it's winter, I'll get us to turn them off all the time that's being recorded, just to make it simpler.
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Fuel consumption experiment
I finally have a good idea that will probably work. I am planning to investigate the relationship between the average speed of a car and the fuel consumption. Data will be collected from the trip computer records on our car.
Independent variable: average trip speed (km/h)
Dependent variable: fuel consumption per 100km
The car makes a number of journeys on many different routes, which will allow collection of large amounts of data.
Aim: to investigate whether it would be more environmentally friendly to build a motorway through the city, or to maintain the current system of minor roads.
Hypothesis: As the average speed increases, the fuel consumption per 100km will decrease, then begin to increase as air resistance becomes a factor.
The method will involve investigating the fuel consumption of the car over journeys generally (eg. travelling to school, work, and sport), with average speeds, and comparing this to the fuel consumption when driving on routes where more than 50% of the journey's distance takes place on a motorway. This will be quite practical as we frequently drive relatively long distances within the city both along regular roads and also along motorways.
The result of the experiment will be to see whether including more motorways in metropolitan road infrastructure would decrease fuel consumption among family vehicles.
Some variables that need to be controlled: the amount of weight carried by the car will vary sometimes, but this should not affect the experiment as it is averaged out. The only time that this may affect results is if the amount of weight in the car was consistently different for trips on motorways and regular roads.
Independent variable: average trip speed (km/h)
Dependent variable: fuel consumption per 100km
The car makes a number of journeys on many different routes, which will allow collection of large amounts of data.
Aim: to investigate whether it would be more environmentally friendly to build a motorway through the city, or to maintain the current system of minor roads.
Hypothesis: As the average speed increases, the fuel consumption per 100km will decrease, then begin to increase as air resistance becomes a factor.
The method will involve investigating the fuel consumption of the car over journeys generally (eg. travelling to school, work, and sport), with average speeds, and comparing this to the fuel consumption when driving on routes where more than 50% of the journey's distance takes place on a motorway. This will be quite practical as we frequently drive relatively long distances within the city both along regular roads and also along motorways.
The result of the experiment will be to see whether including more motorways in metropolitan road infrastructure would decrease fuel consumption among family vehicles.
Some variables that need to be controlled: the amount of weight carried by the car will vary sometimes, but this should not affect the experiment as it is averaged out. The only time that this may affect results is if the amount of weight in the car was consistently different for trips on motorways and regular roads.
Ideas and why they were discarded
I realised I have had a number of ideas for my research project, most of which I have discarded.
1. Measuring amount of metals in soils and seeing whether this increases near roads. The independent variable would be the distance from the road, and the dependent variable would be the amount of metal. This would have been a good experiment, but it might be hard to measure the exact distance between roads, and there could be other variables such as the number of cars on the particular road, and the natural type of soil. Another practical consideration was the method of isolating metal from the soil: using magnets would only collect magnetic metals.
2. Investigating the relative success rates of various types of memorisation. The independent variable being the type of memorisation (listening, reading, looking at pictures) and the dependent variable being the number remembered correctly from the list. However, this would be difficult to find enough people, and other variables such as age and gender may be unevenly distributed among the sample groups. It might be hard to make a hypothesis, as it is difficult to find a starting point on what is likely to be the most successful method.
3. Does applying topical antiseptic/antifungal cream to a plant prevent or treat disease? The independent variable would be the type of cream used, and the dependent variable would be how long the plants survived before being overcome by the disease, or, if using baby plants, what height they grew to still having the disease.
This would be difficult to measure accurately, as the variables would be hard to control, including the initial dose of disease introduced to infect the plant (I was thinking of grinding up infected leaves from other plants and either sprinkling them in the plants or putting them in water then pouring it on the plants). Also, the plant disease may be a virus, which would not react to antiseptic or antifungal treatment.
4. How much wind can bean plants tolerate before they die? This would be quite easy to control in terms of variables, by sitting each plant in front of a fan on a particular setting for an hour a day. The independent variable would be the fan setting, and the dependent variable would be whether the plants die and the height they reach. Again, it could be difficult to control all variables, because even if the plants were put in front of the same fan, there would be a risk that other factors, such as the time of day the "wind" occured, that might affect the experiment. There is also the risk that the plant disease infecting my other plants would reach experimental plants and destroy the experiment.
5. How far from light can a bean plant grow from? According to thinkquest.com, the process of plants growing toward light is called "phototropism", and occurs as a result of a chemical called auxin (http://library.thinkquest.org/15215/Friend/plants.html). This would be interesting to investigate. The bean seed could be planted 1cm deep in all the pots, but each one would be covered with a different length of tube.
The independent variable would be the tube length, and the dependent variable would be whether the plants lives, and grows up the tube to the light, or fails to germinate or dies. However, this might present difficult-to-control variables including the fact that a plant with a shorter tube would not only be closer to light; it would get more light due to the angles of rays entering. It might also be cooler at the bottom of a long tube, or less water might be lost, creating other variables.
1. Measuring amount of metals in soils and seeing whether this increases near roads. The independent variable would be the distance from the road, and the dependent variable would be the amount of metal. This would have been a good experiment, but it might be hard to measure the exact distance between roads, and there could be other variables such as the number of cars on the particular road, and the natural type of soil. Another practical consideration was the method of isolating metal from the soil: using magnets would only collect magnetic metals.
2. Investigating the relative success rates of various types of memorisation. The independent variable being the type of memorisation (listening, reading, looking at pictures) and the dependent variable being the number remembered correctly from the list. However, this would be difficult to find enough people, and other variables such as age and gender may be unevenly distributed among the sample groups. It might be hard to make a hypothesis, as it is difficult to find a starting point on what is likely to be the most successful method.
3. Does applying topical antiseptic/antifungal cream to a plant prevent or treat disease? The independent variable would be the type of cream used, and the dependent variable would be how long the plants survived before being overcome by the disease, or, if using baby plants, what height they grew to still having the disease.
This would be difficult to measure accurately, as the variables would be hard to control, including the initial dose of disease introduced to infect the plant (I was thinking of grinding up infected leaves from other plants and either sprinkling them in the plants or putting them in water then pouring it on the plants). Also, the plant disease may be a virus, which would not react to antiseptic or antifungal treatment.
4. How much wind can bean plants tolerate before they die? This would be quite easy to control in terms of variables, by sitting each plant in front of a fan on a particular setting for an hour a day. The independent variable would be the fan setting, and the dependent variable would be whether the plants die and the height they reach. Again, it could be difficult to control all variables, because even if the plants were put in front of the same fan, there would be a risk that other factors, such as the time of day the "wind" occured, that might affect the experiment. There is also the risk that the plant disease infecting my other plants would reach experimental plants and destroy the experiment.
5. How far from light can a bean plant grow from? According to thinkquest.com, the process of plants growing toward light is called "phototropism", and occurs as a result of a chemical called auxin (http://library.thinkquest.org/15215/Friend/plants.html). This would be interesting to investigate. The bean seed could be planted 1cm deep in all the pots, but each one would be covered with a different length of tube.
The independent variable would be the tube length, and the dependent variable would be whether the plants lives, and grows up the tube to the light, or fails to germinate or dies. However, this might present difficult-to-control variables including the fact that a plant with a shorter tube would not only be closer to light; it would get more light due to the angles of rays entering. It might also be cooler at the bottom of a long tube, or less water might be lost, creating other variables.
Tuesday, March 9, 2010
Idea for science research project (finally)
I'm thinking seriously about doing a psychological test involving memory, and which form of memorising a "list" of object is the most effective -- listening to the listed words, looking at a written list, or looking at pictures of the objects.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)